Cancelling Factors: Why the Missing Input Stays Missing
Function value versus limit
Practise turning a calculation into a justified argument. Start with a short exercise on continuity and derivatives, then choose the step you want to work on.
The official scope includes logic, quantifiers, sets, induction, limits, continuity, differentiation and the mean value theorem. Your section’s outline sets the teaching order and assessment scope.
Try this after you have met continuity and the derivative definition. It is a focused sample of reasoning, not a test of readiness for the whole course. The exercise is original practice, not a U of T assessment.
Let x be a real input and let a and b be real constants. Define f on all real numbers by:
When : .
.
When : .
compare the two one-sided function limits with , then compare the two one-sided difference quotients.
As x approaches 1 from below, approaches . From above, approaches 3. Continuity requires both limits to equal the assigned value . Thus continuity holds exactly when .
Let h be a nonzero real displacement from 1, so the nearby input is . As h approaches zero through negative values, approaches 1 from the left; through positive values, it approaches from the right. The derivative is the limit, as h approaches zero, of:
Using , for this quotient is:
For it is:
The two quotient limits are a and 2. They must be the same finite number, so ; continuity then gives . Conversely, these values make the left quotient 2 and the right quotient , both tending to 2. Therefore the unique differentiable pair is , and .
What this checks: continuity compares nearby values with . Differentiability also compares rates of change. Matching the values alone does not settle the derivative.
Set and . Is f continuous at 1? Is it differentiable there? Explain both answers before opening the solution.
Continuity holds because . The one-sided difference-quotient limits are 0 and 2, so no derivative exists at 1. The graph has a corner there. This gives a counterexample to the claim that every continuous function is differentiable.
A student differentiates the two branch formulas, matches their slopes at 1, and chooses , . Why is the argument incomplete?
The left function limit is 2, while and the right limit are 3. The join is not continuous. More directly, the left difference quotient is:This quotient has no finite limit as h approaches zero from below. The derivative of a branch away from the join does not establish the derivative at the join.
Let g be a real-valued function defined on an open interval containing 1. Suppose exists and is finite. Use the identity below to show that g is continuous at 1.
The quotient tends to , while h tends to zero. The product limit is 0 · = 0. Hence tends to , which is continuity at 1. The first practice question shows why the converse fails.
Function value versus limit
Proof structure and the induction step
Calculation practice after the definition
These are shared topic resources. Their other course connections do not make those courses equivalent to MAT148H1.
Bring a question or a concept you want explained, even if you have not started a solution. If you have tried a definition or theorem, you can include that work. Your tutor can help you:
You can choose the first step together or review the point where your reasoning became unclear.
The MAT148H1 and MAT149H1 calendar entries both list MAT137Y1 as their previous course number. This guide focuses on MAT148H1; MAT149H1 is a separate course covering integral calculus and series. Check your current outline or enrolment record, especially when using older MAT137 materials.
These are different courses. MAT135H1 develops applied differential calculus, including linear approximation and Euler’s method. MAT136H1 continues the applied sequence with integration, series and differential equations. MAT148H1 includes foundations based on mathematical proofs. Use the guide matching your course, and ask U of T about eligibility, exclusions or substitutions.
The MAT148H1 calendar lists high-school-level calculus. For study preparation, review function notation, algebra and how to state assumptions clearly. Those study suggestions are not extra enrolment requirements. Consult the official entry for exclusions.
U of T lists MAT148H1 among new courses approved for Fall 2026. That approval does not by itself verify a particular section or an available seat. Check the official timetable and your course site for current arrangements.
The website and this practice guide are available in French; tutoring sessions are in English. Send your course code, topic and preferred times. You can include a question or any work you have started, but an attempted solution is not required. Nablio confirms coverage, availability and booking details before payment. A request does not reserve a session.
No. Nablio is independent of the university. This page provides original practice and links to official course information. Follow your instructor’s rules for assessed work; a tutor can help you understand and revise your own reasoning.